Posted by: jeannineatkins | January 1, 2013

Anna Karenina: Without the Showy Curtains

I started rereading Anna Karenina in November, knowing I’d want to see the new movie, and knowing it couldn’t convey the kinds of reflections Tolstoy gives us with his omniscient point of view and a focus on three couples. But I was excited to have snow for the outing, and I made Emily wear her faux fur hat while I got out a big black coat. I was happily sitting between my daughter and husband, when only a few minutes into the movie my heart sank.

Because I’d been reading the word “rounded” to describe Anna’s beauty, I hadn’t expected much of Kiera Knightly, but I was won over by her grace and sparkle that came off as both charming and fragile. The screenplay seemed thin, but I’d known it couldn’t cover the novel’s hundreds of pages and I wouldn’t get enough of Levin and Kitty. But I was dismayed by the broken fourth wall, the showy curtains and signage, way that the characters stepped across ladders or sandbags to new scenes, the cameras backed off to reveal frames, being reminded that the parlor, skating rink, or opera house were only stage sets. These had been characters that I loved, but this approach made me feel such a distance that I’d felt more in the hedgehog scene in The Hobbit than in the crucial train station scene. Driving home, when I asked Peter and Em if the movie made them want to read the book, I wasn’t surprised they said no. The movie kept to the plot, but rather than hinting at the reflections and feelings under the surface, the stagy presentation turned everything into a soap opera.

Almost everything I loved was missing, and there’s so much I love in this novel. Not every single page — there were skimmable ones about various bureaucracies, though even then, or when Tolystoy’s most cynical in court houses, there’s something: I liked Anna’s husband consulting a lawyer who tried to look serious, but couldn’t help trying to catch moths during their conversation. There’s not a character here you can’t help liking to some degree, for Tolstoy shines light onto all angles of their souls – a word he uses often. The point of view of Anna’s son is heartbreaking, as the little boy tries to understand Count Vronsky, who his mother clearly likes, while no one else in the house does. When Anna leaves with Vronsky, the little boy is told she’s dead, but can’t believe that. Nevertheless, we see him struggle with trying to reconcile what he’s told with what he sees, a schism that’s a theme throughout the novel, along with varieties of love, faith, and forgiveness.

The drama comes from moments such as being given layers of thoughts, then, often because of chance and circumstance, an invisible curtain, if there’s any curtain at all,  pulls back for the speech, and people say the opposite of what they planned. But the movie gives us scenes like Anna returning to her old house to see her son, striding, glaring, while the music booms. In the novel, we see her lack of confidence in how she’ll be met, and the servants fret, too, as they remind each other it’s the boy’s birthday and Anna was always kind to them.

The actors did their best. The costumes were charming, with particularly excellent hats, and the scenery would have been good if we hadn’t been continually reminded, Hey, this is just a set. But I’m going to catch up on books I set aside while I was reading Anna Karenina, and maybe later this year, crack open War and Peace.



  1. I haven’t seen the movie, but I did love the book. There is something exuberantly YA about Levin and Kitty, even while other characters are diving over the edge. I liked War and Peace, too (although there are several skimmable areas that would have been edited out to make a stronger book today!). That close-up feeling of being present RIGHT NOW in the book, and close to the characters, is one of the reasons I like it, so I’m sad that the movie took such a long-distance approach.

    • I knew it would be inevitable that it would be a different experience, but I wish the director tried instead of trying to distract us with top hats and handkerchiefs. I hadn’t read Tolstoy, except for the wonderful Death of Ivan Illych, since my twenties, and it was a sweet return. I’m happy to know you’re another Tolstoy lover, Rose!

  2. Well said, Jeannine. I think it is also worth pointing out the unfortunately — and, in retrospect, quite deliberately, I think — misleading character of the trailer for the movie, which reveals NONE of the “fourth wall”-breaking silliness which turned an epic book into something tiny and forgettable.

    Since watching the movie with you and Emily, I have given some thought to reading the book, simply BECAUSE it was so obviously shabbily-treated in this adaptation.

  3. Yes, did the marketers know how many would be dismayed? I stayed away from reviews, knowing I wanted to see the dresses and sets and wheat fields, or I might have been steeled. My broken-spined copy awaits if the mood strikes!

  4. I’ve hesitated to see this movie and now I must thank you for warning me off it. Perhaps I’ll see it when it comes out in DVD. I haven’t read the book (I know, I know). Thanks for sharing your insightful and thoughtful review!

    • I predict it will be out on dvd quite soon. Emily and I enjoyed Silver Linings Playbook much more!

      • I hear great things about Silver Linings Playbook. Alas, one thing I greatly miss about CA is the ease of getting to big theaters with many choices of viewing times.

  5. Makes me want to read the book again for sure! (And not see the movie!)

    • It’s a good winter book. I’ve enjoyed a few more books since I finished reading, but coming to the end was bittersweet: despite the book’s size, I liked being in that world.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: