Posted by: jeannineatkins | April 19, 2010

English Majors Give Thumbs Up to Two Nonfiction Picture Books

My children’s literature students are almost entirely English majors, trained, of course, in the art of critique. It seems you can hand them a nonfiction picture book, even a very pretty one, and it’s not hard for them to rip it apart. It had better not to be too long. It had better not be what they’re unafraid to call boring. It had better move beyond facts, eschew big words and a show-off attitude, and keep a tight focus on the subject. They are not daunted by stickers on the cover; if it’s didactic it’s didactic. If the author drones on about volcanoes, sharks, the Inuit, or Leonardo da Vinci, they will say so. They scared me a little bit. Hey, everything can’t be, say, Lily’s Purple Plastic Purse.

But there was some love, too. The students liked the intimate tone and the way the narration kept to a child’s point of view in One Thousand Tracings, written and illustrated by Lita Judge http://www.litajudge.com/ They liked the endpapers with photographs of old boxes that Lita found in an attic and that inspired the story. The book is based on a girl, Lita’s mother, who helped collect penciled or cut-out tracings of feet so that shoes the right size could be sent to those who had little food and clothing after World War II.

My students approved of the way the war and Europe were kept to the background, while a child’s curiosity and care were up front. They liked the tactile and relatively small images of shoes and brown paper, and how something that could be held in the hand might raise bigger questions about the world if a reader desired. But issues weren’t slammed down upon them.

Another book that met with their high-bar approval was Planting the Trees of Kenya: The Story of Wangari Maathi by Claire A. Nivola. A group who focused on biography and nature liked the quote form Maathai on the book’s back: “Remember what millions of hands can do.” They felt this philosophy was reflected in the book, which is naturally about the Nobel prize winning founder of the Green Belt movement, but shows her in the context of other people and not smack in the center. You see that in this picture, too.

Both of these favorite books were written and illustrated by one person. Both have received a lot of acclaim, but so had most of the other books students read and dismissed. The art is lovely in both, but the tones are soft and the style more realistic than not; neither used a layout that called attention to itself. Many of the other books used bigger pictures, bolder colors, more experimental design. The tone and pace of the writing, like the art, is quiet: no one seems to be trying too hard. Perhaps what made these books stand out was the warm and clear connection the creators had with their subjects. Both books have someone who cares about others at their centers. Maybe that’s what we were drawn to. True stories with a beating heart.

For more Nonfiction Monday links, please visit: http://blog.wrappedinfoil.com/

Advertisements

Responses

  1. “True stories with a beating heart.” – nicely put. Also, nice point about not trying too hard.

  2. These also strike me as being more of the “quiet” picture books that theoretically don’t sell as well. Clearly there is appeal when a book is done well.
    I utterly agree with your students liking for One Thousand Tracings. It strikes me as being like A New Coat for Anna and The Lily Cupboard in the way it approaches a large, potentially devastating topic in a way that a child can not only grasp, but fully understand, without being preachy.

  3. I can like a book that knocks me down, but also have had so many lovely moments with books that don’t yell.

  4. It was interesting to me that people around 21, who know the facts, would be drawn to some books that take note of the big world, but also kind of crouch like a teacher helping you button a jacket and talk to you face to face.
    Thank you for the picture book recommendations, Kathy. I’m afraid I’ve missed those, and will look for them. You are a treasure trove!

  5. What an interesting post! Haven’t seen One Thousand Tracings and am intrigued! “True stories with a beating heart.” So well said.

  6. beating hearts
    Wouldn’t it be interesting to do a blind study in which children and your students evaluate an identical set of books, using the same criteria (with age-appropriate words/rating systems, of course)? I wonder if they’d find the same pulse…

  7. The cover of Planting the Trees of Kenya really draws me in. It’s so interesting to hear what your students have to say! I’m putting both of these on my list. 🙂

  8. I think you’d like One Thousand Tracings. And there’s very cool back story on Lita’s website, with somehow poignant photos of shoes traced on old newspapers.

  9. Re: beating hearts
    It would be an interesting study. But of course that pulse is so hard to gauge. Sometimes it seems a small heartening miracle when we all love the same things.

  10. I think you’ll like these! There are other very good books about Wangari Maathai, all coming out after she won that Nobel, but this may be meant more for older readers,(though it is strange, as one student pointed out, that while that’s so, some of the other books draw more attention to the attacks and imprisonment she faced). And the trees here are gorgeous!

  11. Writers take note
    This post should be required reading for all would-be children’s book writers.
    I think it is also interesting that both books were written and illustrated by the same person.
    Thanks!
    -Roberta

  12. Re: Writers take note
    Thank you for your comment, Roberta!

  13. Hi Jeannine — thanks so much for using TRACINGS in your class — and a nice pairing of books too! I’ve really been enjoying BORROWED NAMES, been reading it very slowly. It’s one of my favorite books of all time!

  14. I’ve always liked Tracings, but I also like some other books my students seemed ho-hum about, so that reinforced my feeling about Tracing’s power. Good job! And I’m so happy to hear you like Borrowed Names!

  15. инструментальный альбом скачать
    папины дочки скачать без регистрации варианты егэ 2011 скачать [url=http://neukicolcha.tk/vestov-skachat-albom-341.html]вестов скачать альбом[/url] скачать через торрент nba ольга бузова скачать песни скачать альбом голая [url=http://ohhoningsand.tk/8500-skachat-draiver-453.html]8500 скачать драйвер[/url] скачать в игры
    avira personal 10 rus скачать [url=http://jiaperhyaspur.tk/civilisation-3-skachat-torrent-809.html]civilisation 3 скачать торрент[/url] civilisation 5 русификатор скачать скачать пдд 2011 через торрент скачать анимации на телефон скачать альбом форсаж [url=http://weahaltirest.tk/skachat-kameru-dlya-skaipa-399.html]скачать камеру для скайпа[/url] скачать игру gta sa торрент изучение иностранных языков скачать князь 2 скачать торрент
    tony hawk 4 скачать торрент скачать презентацию животные красной книги [url=http://courtucerfhorn.tk/petrova-skachat-knigi-272.html]петрова скачать книги[/url] 4 post скачать клип блич скачать фильм торрент скачать русскую версию blender [url=http://susvdartitab.tk/gia-lysenko-2011-skachat-20.html]гиа лысенко 2011 скачать[/url] скачать мп3 альбом 2011
    gta 2010 скачать торрент [url=http://linknizotor.tk/skachat-torrent-igry-2011-goda-715.html]скачать торрент игры 2011 года[/url] скачать dichat на компьютер mp3 романтические скачать скачать музыку зайцев нету интерны скачать 4 сезон [url=http://leapfdarphose.tk/skachat-igru-mortal-kombat-2011-566.html]скачать игру mortal kombat 2011[/url] создать видео скачать скачать карты на телефон нокиа улицы скачать mp3
    скачать темы на звонок скачать последнюю версию агента [url=http://laypresmeipho.tk/windows-mobile-6.5-skachat-609.html]windows mobile 6.5 скачать[/url] скачать слав скачать игру герои через торрент скачать nhl 2011 [url=http://cloudatstoriph.tk/windows-bluetooth-skachat-380.html]windows bluetooth скачать[/url] скачать программу для скачивания смс
    скачать need for speed 2010 [url=http://cloudatstoriph.tk/skachat-patrushev-uchebnik-ispanskogo-yazyka-944.html]скачать патрушев учебник испанского языка[/url] скачать программу для бесплатных звонков скачать драйвер для cd скачать игры барби полные версии скачать windows 7 rtm final [url=http://staranserne.tk/skachat-antivirus-dlya-vindovs-7-57.html]скачать антивирус для виндовс 7[/url] скачать песни барских rus проигрыватель скачать скачать айтюнс на русском языке
    скачать денди на компьютер скачать windows xp flash [url=http://ciolessrewhi.tk/skachat-qip-na-kompyuter-500.html]скачать qip на компьютер[/url] как настроение скачать скачать майл скачать ключ avast 5.0 rus [url=http://witzreconsi.tk/programmy-dlya-obucheniya-skachat-921.html]программы для обучения скачать[/url] скачать word 2007
    скачать подбор ключей [url=http://tiotratollog.tk/star-wars-unleashed-skachat-torrent-841.html]star wars unleashed скачать торрент[/url] скачать без регистрации донцову abbyy finereader 9.0 скачать ключ скачать песню хит 2010 скачать музыку mars [url=http://cloreatormic.tk/asus-m2n-draivera-skachat-246.html]asus m2n драйвера скачать[/url] скачать порно букиной светы скачать mp3 video скачать картинки на телефон nokia

  16. скачать словарь неологизмов русского языка
    скачать смс интернет скачать fl 4 [url=http://ankitliren.tk/skate-3-skachat-na-pc-491.html]skate 3 скачать на pc[/url] mozilla 4.0 rus скачать скачать драйвера audigy скачать альбомы по прямым ссылкам [url=http://linknizotor.tk/skachat-minusa-86.html]скачать минуса[/url] скачать фильмы через торрент 2010
    крик 4 dvdrip скачать торрент [url=http://verplatourrio.tk/skachat-windows-media-centre-xp-358.html]скачать windows media centre xp[/url] killzone 2 скачать торрент скачать черное зеркало 3 торрент скачать игры компьютер через торрент скачать скачать mp3 bruno mars [url=http://sightermore.tk/skachat-spb-3-247.html]скачать spb 3[/url] скачать музыку короткую редактирование видео на русском скачать скачать книгу маргарита королева
    pes 2010 патчи скачать торрент скачать ключи касперского kis 2011 [url=http://nutrerihel.tk/skachat-s-ru-801.html]скачать с ru[/url] скачать скайп бес смс как скачать с vimeo ключ windows xp professional скачать [url=http://demeresaf.tk/skachat-igru-ferma-na-telefon-556.html]скачать игру ферма на телефон[/url] скачать игру косынка
    скачать фильм чистилище торрент [url=http://manlinanmo.tk/skachat-fotoshop-na-kompyuter-russkii-907.html]скачать фотошоп на компьютер русский[/url] скачать методичку по английскому языку prigajushie chelovechki скачать на телефон скачать игры для samsung s5230 скачать wonderful mp3 [url=http://tapdivamal.tk/radeon-5450-skachat-draiver-655.html]radeon 5450 скачать драйвер[/url] скачать домашние задания 7 класс bleach heat soul 7 скачать скачать как достать саседа
    скачать песни через torrent скачать фильм через torrentino [url=http://cloudatstoriph.tk/cifrovoe-video-skachat-389.html]цифровое видео скачать[/url] drdamage 3.3 5 a скачать видео винкс 5 сезон скачать реп скачать mp3 [url=http://hieristersdark.tk/evropa-skachat-pesni-469.html]европа скачать песни[/url] скачать бухгалтерские книги
    изнасилование скачать без регистрации [url=http://coeresvaifreel.tk/windows-7-polnoe-rukovodstvo-skachat-534.html]windows 7 полное руководство скачать[/url] скачать mortal kombat видео скачать программу для документов паскаль 7 скачать скачать альбом слава [url=http://sightermore.tk/microsoft-visual-studio-2010-skachat-482.html]microsoft visual studio 2010 скачать[/url] gta 4 1.0 6.1 скачать скачать флеш игры mod скачать
    скачать неро 8 русская версия скачать windows cd [url=http://kaastacmivi.tk/skachat-probnuyu-versiyu-maikrosoft-ofis-320.html]скачать пробную версию майкрософт офис[/url] много фильмов скачать через торрент скачать сборник клипов 2011 затаившиеся скачать фильм [url=http://tyamelconfder.tk/film-alf-skachat-torrent-755.html]фильм альф скачать торрент[/url] скачать ultimate ninja 5
    скачать скайп для mac os [url=http://serticonsbo.tk/budilnik-na-kompyuter-skachat-160.html]будильник на компьютер скачать[/url] скачать музыкальную музыку игра остров секретов скачать торрент скачать blender на русском языке скачать торрент 3.0 через торрент [url=http://dulitohu.tk/skachat-minusovku-takogo-kak-putin-421.html]скачать минусовку такого как путин[/url] русские программы скачать для компьютера скачать через торрент zoo скачать naruto 3


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

%d bloggers like this: